What is Good in this NEW Army Book
We just saw the "release" of this new book. I have looked through it and there are many things that stick out. as an overview i will focus on a few things as well as a general overview. Most armies in the armies of middle earth just got expanded. That is one major thing to note. Army lists that are really good (or at least look really good on paper) consist of, the Grief of Eomer, Khazad Dum, Army of the Great Eye, Umbar, Moria, And the Easterlings. Additionally ones we already have but are in the book such as Fornost, Arnor, and Buhdurs Horde all fall under the good. The grand army of the south is if something even worse then last edition and most lists are better then it. The grey company has remained nearly unchanged while being horrible last edition and still is and took a nerf through the twins being 2 might now instead of 3. One that is/or certainly will bring in much debate is the fiefdoms. Imrahil is still very very good but now you have to pay the points for him with 190 points for him mounted. Many are calling him overcosted but if you did a points to points calculation from last edition with nearly any other hero in the game imrahil was at least 30-40 points undercosted if not more. He was right there with the Dragon Emperors power and only a few points below with the loss of the elven blade, no magical resistance and i guess a big fat hard to move base that does extra attacks instead of his versatile horse with a lance... His banner is reduced his standfast is better and he is now a true beat stick. He is technically 170 to compare with last edition but now the horses cost more as well as heroes in general. He still has a lot of good value and is nothing to sniff at.
Khazad Dum and its antithesis Moria are the two lists that stood out the most to me. Khazad dum can cover a quarter of the board with mirrors which are actually very very good. They gain dominant 2 on captains and the warriors and rangers (which is utter insanity), as well as whenever you are outnumbered in a duel roll by dice you may reroll a dice for free, so if its an iron guard or a captain they can go up to 4 attacks in the duel roll if there is a banner near... this rule is very very good. They still reroll ones, and now dwarf rangers... my word... this list is to me the best list in the game hands down. Now that being said it still requires a highly skilled player to be that. This list still has no normal spears other then vault wardens. It still is a very different playstyle to every other list in the game but man if someone knows mastery of this list it is basically untouchable. So much to the point that I am only playing Durin, Mardin, the legacy balin, in tournaments and for casual play only using captains and 1 king. It is just so powerful. I played 2 games with spam rangers and it quartered a barad dur in 4 turns of shooting, It killed a legolas through 4 in the ways with shooting in 3 turns and killed about 7 minas tirith warriors in those same turns and followed it up by beating the list. Let me break it down... rangers were what i loved last edition for khazad dum and now they are even better. They were hard to use last edition but this edition they are good... not great but good... insane in the hands of a great player but in a starter or a mediocre player they wont do much and you will very rarely win because this is a skill based troop and army. Simply put place your army in ruins or difficult terrain... force your enemy to you then you gain the same buffs as dale as rangers now have plus 1 to wound in ruins or difficult terrain rerolling 1s and access to two handed weapons. Then they have throwing weapons... their bows this edition are 24 inch s3 bows hitting on 3s. They outshoot everything except tie legolas simply because of the mirrors. They have a ballistae which offsets a windlance, they still have d7 and banners. They have great numbers, great hitting power in i would always take 4-8 iron guards. This list is SO good. It has just taken my spot for Nova and nothing will change that. Even if they get nerfed I kinda hope they do so they are less appealing but even then the armored version is easier to play and more consistent without a lot of skill.
Moria as i said earlier also stands out. You get numbers, shenanigans, a beastcaller, dragons, drakes, trolls, bats, prowlers, goblins, fell wargs, everything... It is so powerful. It is the AoL of last edition or more accurately the angmar of last edition in the fact that you have a bunch of tricks they just need skill to be pulled off. You need to engage correctly use you monsters well and use your bat swarms in the right times. This has a much lower ceiling then the khazad dum as you have all the basics and numbers to make it forgiving. If you take durburz a captain, druzhag and a drake and then spam goblins with some prowlers 2 bats a few fell wargs you are looking at a VERY good list. Durburz can elect to not move in a turn to let all other Moria goblins move 7 inches instead that turn which can be devastating and so effective for charging things such as cavalry or other such lists. Or in recon it can also help.
Army of the great eye looks fun for a numenorean line with shelob and the witch king. It is the same list as was Britains meta without suladan and is still brutally effective.
easterling warriors with 2 pikes behind gain plus 1 to wound which means d6 is easy to crack for the easterlings now making the dragon emporers list very reliable and good now.
Fornost is still a top 3 list alongside khazad dum and the army of the white hand so not much to say on that or the other arnor/angmar armies as we have had those for a bit.
Frankly I think this book is very good and I like the anticipation that was given by GW rather then releasing all 3 books at once and now its almost as if we just got the whole game new again and it is so fun. Matched play guide looks excellent and so many different ways to do veto now. Cannot wait to see these armies making the table... and please... dont run khazad dum... let me play my baby which was the first army i ever bought